Ticket geändert von camel camel am 2009/07/16 01:48
Verfolgungssystem: Bugs
Kategorie: SyncML
Version: Trunk
Status: Offen
Lösung: Keine
Prozent erledigt: 0%
Priorität: 5 - mittlere
Erstellt von: camel camel
Zugewiesen an: Jörg Lehrke
Zusammenfassung: #2163 - RECOVER SYNC - calendar/contacts - TESTS are not exact the same
hi,
so i test now RECOVER SYNC in detail.
the idea for checking is:
to sync all appointments tofrom outlook to EGW (recover sync delete all old appointments on server or on outlook) - depends on direction.
then i can compare if all appointments are the same or if something is missing.
well i did it: (calendar items 1111)
1.) RECOVER SYNC all appointments from Outlook to EGW
then
2.) backup/copy all appointments in outlook to compare folder "calendar_compare"
3.) RECOVER SYNC all appointments from EGW to Outlook
and it works without an error, but …there are differents
and then i compare the appointments on outlook with the calendar: “calendar_compare”
BUG:
what i see is: (1085 from 1111 are complete the same)
differents are in detail:
1.) all birthdays are different with 1 hour - so they are different to orig.
ex:
outlook orig: Geburtstag von Christian 22.10.1962 00:00
EGW’s sync: Geburtstag von Christian 22.10.1962 01:00
2.) special chars are handled different
ex:
outlook orig: Christbaum richten mit Trinkl’s
EGW’s sync: Christbaum richten mit Trinkl’s
ex:
outlook orig: bei "Freiwilligen Vesicherung"
EGW’s sync: bei “Freiwilligen Vesicherung”
3.) on contacts are did the same and it was looking almost good (excluded the saveas and so it is different)
ex:
outlook orig: saveas: "Wutzlbauer, Hans (Firma X)"
EGW’s sync: saveas: “Herr Hans Wutzlbauer”
some ideas what it can be ?
to 1: 1hr different - time zone ? bug ?
to 2: i have configured UTF8 - bug ?
to 3: i have configured “Name, Surename (Company)” in EGW settings and own sort is also set to this options, and further also set in outlook as default- so why is it different ? bug ?
Kommentar von camel camel am 2009/07/16 01:48:
sorry, maybe i don’t wrote it clearly - let me try once again
if i sync from OUTLOOK TO EGW (via RECOVER sync)
it is almost working perfect !!!
if i sync from EGW to OUTLOOK (via RECOVER sync)
There are some fileds which are not working perfect or they are missing.
in which fields are bugs -> see comments again:
calendar:
a.) all birthdays are different with 1 hour - so they are different to orig.
ex:
outlook orig: Geburtstag von Christian 22.10.1962 00:00
EGW’s sync: Geburtstag von Christian 22.10.1962 01:00
b.) special chars are handled different
ex:
outlook orig: Christbaum richten mit Trinkl’s
EGW’s sync: Christbaum richten mit Trinkl’s
(quote will be done via the html ex: space via nsp… - translation code - i can’t do it here, because the quote will in php changed back)
ex:
outlook orig: bei "Freiwilligen Vesicherung"
EGW’s sync: bei “Freiwilligen Vesicherung”
contacts:
c.) it seems to be, that “n_fn” will be used for outlook field “saveas”, but it should be "n_fileas"
in db “n_fileas” is complete the same like in outlook.
it was correct, but after syncing to outlook wrong !
ex:
outlook orig: saveas: "Wutzlbauer, Hans (Firma X)"
after EGW’s sync: saveas: “Herr Hans Wutzlbauer”
d:) some fields will be not handled or delete the values
i created a contact (fullfilled all fields) in EGW and sync it to outlook:
and there are some missing fields or diff. fields
.)“Birthday” is empty on outlook
.)“fax business” on egw is on outlook “fax privat”
.)“fax privat” is empty on outlook
.)“tel Assistent” is empty on outlook
.)“tel Auto” is empty on outlook
.)“tel other” is empty on outlook
tried on latest trunk 27449 + 27451
Kommentar von camel camel am 2009/07/16 00:44:
really ?
syncing from EGW to outlook doesn’t work correctly !
which fields not working i made comments.
see comments before.
also:
but i have seen, that “n_fn will” be used for syncing from EGW to outlook for “saveas” field in OL.
but it should be EGW’s “n_fileas” to outlook’s "saveas"
this seems to be wrong
Kommentar von Jörg Lehrke am 2009/07/16 00:04:
2. I don’t get the point???
Kommentar von Jörg Lehrke am 2009/07/16 00:02:
- Don’t store Birthdays within the Outlook Calendar. Outlook does not handle these properly. You will alway end up with a mess due to TZ issues. Keep these dates in you contacts.
Kommentar von Jörg Lehrke am 2009/07/15 23:59: - is #2160 again
Kommentar von camel camel am 2009/07/15 23:20:
on bug 3 - i checked the db. in the db the n_fileas there it is the same as it is in outlook.
so for me, it seems to be, that on RECOVER SYNCING FROM EGW TO OL - there is the problem.
i’m testing with the lastest trunk 27449
@ralf
thanks for merging syncml-1.2 to trunk
Kommentar von camel camel am 1970/01/01 01:00:
on bug 3 - maybe this also belongs to bug: #2160
Linked entries:
http://www.egroupware.org/egroupware/index.php?menuaction=tracker.tracker_ui.edit&tr_id=2163&no_popup=1